EDITOR: Peter Schweighofer
COPYRIGHT: 1997
SERIES: Tales From... (well, sort of)
TIME FRAME: Rebellion through New Republic -- covers stories from shortly after the Battle of Yavin to after the Thrawn trilogy
Unlike the other short story anthologies in the Star Wars "Tales From..." series, the stories published in this volume all originally appeared in Star Wars Adventure Journal. This publication is a tie-in to the officially licensed Star Wars role-playing games put out by West End Games. Given its association with role-playing games, some of the stories included are by first-time freelancers and some stories have an RPG feel to them as if based on personal game campaigns. Because these expanded tales do not revolve our the series' classic protagonists, sometimes we instead get carbon copies of these "types" which isn't always enjoyable by comparison.
Other stories are from established authors in the Star Wars expanded universe, like Timothy Zahn and Michael Stackpole, who use the Adventure Journal as opportunity to tell more stories with their own Star Wars characters who appear in later novels.
I do wish the book had more of a chronological organization to it, as stories jump all around the timeline. The current "official" timeline that is being published at the start of Star Wars novels now lists both Tales From the Empire and Tales From the New Republic shortly after Episode IV, and that is lazy and inaccurate. At least half of the stories here are set after Jedi. There is a certain logic to some of the organization, ending with a short story that finally includes Darth Vader, the only original series character to appear in the anthology. But when we have one story where a character is one age and then later one about his childhood, it's sometimes hard to keep straight where they are.
I would recommend reading these stories only after reading some of the other works referenced in them. Or perhaps alongside them, for example the short story that sets up the X-Wing series with that series. Reading this anthology on its own, especially before reading the other works, has far less of an impact.
While the anthology is sometimes a mixed bag, I found it more consistently enjoyable than Tales From the Mos Eisley Cantina, and some of the freelancers tell very good stories. I wonder why these stories specifically were chosen out of the many the Adventure Journal had published, and whether other stories were never anthologized.
Other stories are from established authors in the Star Wars expanded universe, like Timothy Zahn and Michael Stackpole, who use the Adventure Journal as opportunity to tell more stories with their own Star Wars characters who appear in later novels.
I do wish the book had more of a chronological organization to it, as stories jump all around the timeline. The current "official" timeline that is being published at the start of Star Wars novels now lists both Tales From the Empire and Tales From the New Republic shortly after Episode IV, and that is lazy and inaccurate. At least half of the stories here are set after Jedi. There is a certain logic to some of the organization, ending with a short story that finally includes Darth Vader, the only original series character to appear in the anthology. But when we have one story where a character is one age and then later one about his childhood, it's sometimes hard to keep straight where they are.
I would recommend reading these stories only after reading some of the other works referenced in them. Or perhaps alongside them, for example the short story that sets up the X-Wing series with that series. Reading this anthology on its own, especially before reading the other works, has far less of an impact.
While the anthology is sometimes a mixed bag, I found it more consistently enjoyable than Tales From the Mos Eisley Cantina, and some of the freelancers tell very good stories. I wonder why these stories specifically were chosen out of the many the Adventure Journal had published, and whether other stories were never anthologized.
"FIRST CONTACT"
AUTHOR: Timothy Zahn
The first story in this collection is fittingly from the man who almost single-handledly began the Expanded Universe as we know it today. "First Contact" is about a smuggler, Talon Karrde, and his dealings with a weapon smuggling operation fronted by a big game safari. While there is a sort of mystery at the heart of the story that slowly unfolds, I didn't get the sense that Zahn really cared about most of that. The notion that the beasts hunted are actually sentient is never fully explored to any sort of conclusion. It's just a fact introduced and then ignored. What is the "First Contact" of the title? It would seem to be the ending of the story, when Karrde leaves with a female smuggler by the name of Mara Jade. These are characters who figure prominently in Zahn's other Star Wars books, but the reveal of Jade's name at the end is only going to matter to people familiar with these later stories. It's a good story, but a bit unfocused for me.
GRADE: B
"TINIAN ON TRIAL"
AUTHOR: Kathy Tyers
"Tinian on Trial" addresses an issue in the Star Wars universe that has been bothering me for some time now: what good is the Stormtroopers' armor? It seems to provide no defense against blaster fire at all! So Kathy Tyers posits that the armor has weak points that are being targeted, and builds her story around characters who have developed a kind of shielding which would make Stormtroopers impervious to blasters. Tinian is a young woman whose parents created the weapon, and is in love with a man who is in tune with the Force. But when the Empire double-crosses them to take the device as their own, Tinian is forced to defend herself against the Empire she thought she could trust in the name of those she loves. I liked the idea that the Empire has been working on some way to improve Stormtrooper defenses. This was a good story in that vane of nice people realizing just how corrupt the Empire is, and the things that lead people to turn on their government. The title is somewhat deceptive though, since Tinian is never actually "on trial".
GRADE: B
"THE FINAL EXIT"
AUTHOR: Patricia A. Jackson
Here we have a story that definitely seems to have begun as a home game. And unfortunately, that's to its detriment. There are a lot of Star Wars-y things like the Force and smugglers and Jedi but it never feels to me like it belongs here. The characters all seem to be pale imitations of actual characters. The plot concerns a Corellian smuggler (Han Solo knock-off) who is transporting a Jedi (sound familiar?). Only this time, the Jedi is a "dark Jedi" (whatever that is) who also happens to be a famous actor and is on some secret mission for the Emperor or something. Oh, and we meet his kid who wants to be just like him when he grows up, so there are shades of Anakin Skywalker too. This story just doesn't make any sense to me. It's one thing to suppose there are a few other Jedi in hiding like Kenobi and Yoda who weren't killed by the Empire. But to then suggest that one of them is being groomed by the Emperor, I just don't buy it. I understand this was published before we learned of the rule of two with the Sith and all, but even given that, I don't understand why if Palpatine has Vader, he would be screwing with some other Jedi's head instead of just killing him. And the whole "oh, and he's an actor" bit doesn't really add to the story either. The actual writing of the piece is fairly good, but I just can't get past some of these elements.
GRADE: D
"MISSED CHANCE"
AUTHOR: Michael A. Stackpole
Forgive me, as it's been about a month since I read some of these and don't remember them well. "Missed Chance" is a sort of prequel to Stackpole's X-Wing series of novels. It follows Corran Horn as he gets involved with a rag-group of characters and finally is convinced to help the New Republic. Like I say, some of these run together in my head and I don't remember all the particulars, but it was a good read. As I mentioned in my review of the first Star Wars novelization, sometimes the space battle scenes don't read well or are hard to visualize. That did make a little tough for me on this story (though I'm sure there are other readers who love that stuff). That was really my only criticism, though.
GRADE: A
"RETREAT FROM CORUSCANT"
AUTHOR: Laurie Burns
The fun part of reading or writing stories in an existing universe is imagining the everyday workings of the society. Several of the stories collected here involve working-class people in some Star Wars version of a regular job. Set after the reign of Grand Admiral Thrawn, "Retreat From Coruscant" is about, well, the Rebellion's retreat from Coruscant after it is surrounded. What makes it stand out is that they escape by booking transport on a mail courier. It's a fun escapade that balances the mundane of the world (mail delivery) with the fantastic.
GRADE: B
"A CERTAIN POINT OF VIEW"
AUTHOR: Charlene Newcomb
Peter Schweighofer tells us in the introduction that this story was inspired by a painting done for one of the games. You would never know it; it's a masterfully executed piece that explores those things that caused people to rebel against the Empire. It's shortly after Alderaan has been destroyed. Celia's brother was serving in the Imperial forces and had been killed by the Rebels. What follows is a fascinating look at the universe from Imperial sympathizers and how the nature of right and wrong is not necessarily about galactic politics, but personal. It's quite moving at times, and I hadn't really expected much from the cute Star Wars title. But that title ends up packed with symbolism. One of the standout pieces of this collection for me.
GRADE: A
"BLAZE OF GLORY"
AUTHOR: Tony Russo
A rollicking adventure following a band of mercenaries as they take down a slave trade operation. Most of the characters get their own little moments of exploration, and as you'd expect from the title, one of them goes out in a blaze of glory. Again, I no longer remember the particulars, but a perfectly serviceable story. Nothing sticks out as bad, nothing jumps out as memorable, so I'm going to give it a solid grade in the middle.
GRADE: C
"SLAYING DRAGONS"
AUTHOR: Angela Phillips
From the title and the opening paragraphs, I thought I was going to hate this story. I thought it would just be crazy fantastical nonsense with dragon-slaying. Instead, it refers to an old story from Alderaan with a dragonslayer, but that is not the focus. I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the story of nine-year-old hacker Shannon and her cousin Deen. Deen has been working with the Rebels, which the family does not support. It's a nice little family dynamic story. Shannon sneaks off to join Deen and the story ends with a great moment where family have to decide where their loyalties lie.
GRADE: B
"DO NO HARM"
AUTHOR: Erin Endom
Another story from a certain point of view. "Do No Harm" is about a young doctor who is assigned to a team breaking into an Imperial prison to free an aging Rebel leader. Over the course of the story she's quite adamant that she is a healer not a killer, reluctant even to be involved if the objective is more about slaughter than rescue. If they can't get him out, she's asked if she can euthanize him so he can't be interrogated. She initially refuses this, but along the way finds herself put to the test in her role as healer; to save a life, will she take one? (boy, this is good stuff; I should write copy!) I really enjoyed this one, as it's an adventure told by someone who doesn't want to be on one, and reluctant heroes are always fascinating.
GRADE: A
"SIDE TRIP"
AUTHOR: Timothy Zahn and Michael A. Stackpole
This "short novel" as the front cover calls it is broken up into four sections, with Zahn and Stackpole splitting duties between them. Working together, they craft a tale that brings Stackpole's Corran Horn character together with Zahn's Thrawn and it makes for a great read. It's a sort of origin story for Corran, as he's a young boy working with his father in Corellian Security. It begins with some smugglers running guns for the Rebellion who get caught up with the Imperials, drafted to transport cargo to Corellia. To protect their own cargo, they agree.
The other catch is that they are provided with a guide on this mission: a bounty hunter named Jodo Kast in Mandalorian armor. This must be why the cover image is one of Boba Fett, though Fett never appears in this book. Even if the cover is meant to be Kast and not Fett, Fett's ship never appears either. So it's a bit of false advertising there, but I'm sure it helps sell books.
Zahn covers the first part of the story and the last part, while Stackpole takes over for the middle portions which focus more on the smuggler's dealings with Corran Horn when they get to Correlia and the whole situation gets crazy. The plot picks up speed with shifting loyalties, drugs, and the Black Sun criminal underground. I can't do it justice, but each "chapter" as it were ends with a rousing cliffhanger. The story is full of surprises, such as the fact that "Jodo Kast" is really Admiral Thrawn. In the end, Darth Vader himself makes an appearance, having orchestrated the whole episode himself to wipe out Correlia's arm of Black Sun. And Thrawn got something from Vader in return: command of the Noghiri.
The whole story is intricately plotted, well-paced and fun on its own, but it's ties to other novels in the expanded universe give it an extra punch. You'd expect no less from these authors. I can't grade it as four separate pieces, but as one.
GRADE: A
OVERALL ANTHOLOGY GRADE: B
"THE FINAL EXIT"
AUTHOR: Patricia A. Jackson
Here we have a story that definitely seems to have begun as a home game. And unfortunately, that's to its detriment. There are a lot of Star Wars-y things like the Force and smugglers and Jedi but it never feels to me like it belongs here. The characters all seem to be pale imitations of actual characters. The plot concerns a Corellian smuggler (Han Solo knock-off) who is transporting a Jedi (sound familiar?). Only this time, the Jedi is a "dark Jedi" (whatever that is) who also happens to be a famous actor and is on some secret mission for the Emperor or something. Oh, and we meet his kid who wants to be just like him when he grows up, so there are shades of Anakin Skywalker too. This story just doesn't make any sense to me. It's one thing to suppose there are a few other Jedi in hiding like Kenobi and Yoda who weren't killed by the Empire. But to then suggest that one of them is being groomed by the Emperor, I just don't buy it. I understand this was published before we learned of the rule of two with the Sith and all, but even given that, I don't understand why if Palpatine has Vader, he would be screwing with some other Jedi's head instead of just killing him. And the whole "oh, and he's an actor" bit doesn't really add to the story either. The actual writing of the piece is fairly good, but I just can't get past some of these elements.
GRADE: D
"MISSED CHANCE"
AUTHOR: Michael A. Stackpole
Forgive me, as it's been about a month since I read some of these and don't remember them well. "Missed Chance" is a sort of prequel to Stackpole's X-Wing series of novels. It follows Corran Horn as he gets involved with a rag-group of characters and finally is convinced to help the New Republic. Like I say, some of these run together in my head and I don't remember all the particulars, but it was a good read. As I mentioned in my review of the first Star Wars novelization, sometimes the space battle scenes don't read well or are hard to visualize. That did make a little tough for me on this story (though I'm sure there are other readers who love that stuff). That was really my only criticism, though.
GRADE: A
"RETREAT FROM CORUSCANT"
AUTHOR: Laurie Burns
The fun part of reading or writing stories in an existing universe is imagining the everyday workings of the society. Several of the stories collected here involve working-class people in some Star Wars version of a regular job. Set after the reign of Grand Admiral Thrawn, "Retreat From Coruscant" is about, well, the Rebellion's retreat from Coruscant after it is surrounded. What makes it stand out is that they escape by booking transport on a mail courier. It's a fun escapade that balances the mundane of the world (mail delivery) with the fantastic.
GRADE: B
"A CERTAIN POINT OF VIEW"
AUTHOR: Charlene Newcomb
Peter Schweighofer tells us in the introduction that this story was inspired by a painting done for one of the games. You would never know it; it's a masterfully executed piece that explores those things that caused people to rebel against the Empire. It's shortly after Alderaan has been destroyed. Celia's brother was serving in the Imperial forces and had been killed by the Rebels. What follows is a fascinating look at the universe from Imperial sympathizers and how the nature of right and wrong is not necessarily about galactic politics, but personal. It's quite moving at times, and I hadn't really expected much from the cute Star Wars title. But that title ends up packed with symbolism. One of the standout pieces of this collection for me.
GRADE: A
"BLAZE OF GLORY"
AUTHOR: Tony Russo
A rollicking adventure following a band of mercenaries as they take down a slave trade operation. Most of the characters get their own little moments of exploration, and as you'd expect from the title, one of them goes out in a blaze of glory. Again, I no longer remember the particulars, but a perfectly serviceable story. Nothing sticks out as bad, nothing jumps out as memorable, so I'm going to give it a solid grade in the middle.
GRADE: C
"SLAYING DRAGONS"
AUTHOR: Angela Phillips
From the title and the opening paragraphs, I thought I was going to hate this story. I thought it would just be crazy fantastical nonsense with dragon-slaying. Instead, it refers to an old story from Alderaan with a dragonslayer, but that is not the focus. I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the story of nine-year-old hacker Shannon and her cousin Deen. Deen has been working with the Rebels, which the family does not support. It's a nice little family dynamic story. Shannon sneaks off to join Deen and the story ends with a great moment where family have to decide where their loyalties lie.
GRADE: B
"DO NO HARM"
AUTHOR: Erin Endom
Another story from a certain point of view. "Do No Harm" is about a young doctor who is assigned to a team breaking into an Imperial prison to free an aging Rebel leader. Over the course of the story she's quite adamant that she is a healer not a killer, reluctant even to be involved if the objective is more about slaughter than rescue. If they can't get him out, she's asked if she can euthanize him so he can't be interrogated. She initially refuses this, but along the way finds herself put to the test in her role as healer; to save a life, will she take one? (boy, this is good stuff; I should write copy!) I really enjoyed this one, as it's an adventure told by someone who doesn't want to be on one, and reluctant heroes are always fascinating.
GRADE: A
"SIDE TRIP"
AUTHOR: Timothy Zahn and Michael A. Stackpole
This "short novel" as the front cover calls it is broken up into four sections, with Zahn and Stackpole splitting duties between them. Working together, they craft a tale that brings Stackpole's Corran Horn character together with Zahn's Thrawn and it makes for a great read. It's a sort of origin story for Corran, as he's a young boy working with his father in Corellian Security. It begins with some smugglers running guns for the Rebellion who get caught up with the Imperials, drafted to transport cargo to Corellia. To protect their own cargo, they agree.
The other catch is that they are provided with a guide on this mission: a bounty hunter named Jodo Kast in Mandalorian armor. This must be why the cover image is one of Boba Fett, though Fett never appears in this book. Even if the cover is meant to be Kast and not Fett, Fett's ship never appears either. So it's a bit of false advertising there, but I'm sure it helps sell books.
Zahn covers the first part of the story and the last part, while Stackpole takes over for the middle portions which focus more on the smuggler's dealings with Corran Horn when they get to Correlia and the whole situation gets crazy. The plot picks up speed with shifting loyalties, drugs, and the Black Sun criminal underground. I can't do it justice, but each "chapter" as it were ends with a rousing cliffhanger. The story is full of surprises, such as the fact that "Jodo Kast" is really Admiral Thrawn. In the end, Darth Vader himself makes an appearance, having orchestrated the whole episode himself to wipe out Correlia's arm of Black Sun. And Thrawn got something from Vader in return: command of the Noghiri.
The whole story is intricately plotted, well-paced and fun on its own, but it's ties to other novels in the expanded universe give it an extra punch. You'd expect no less from these authors. I can't grade it as four separate pieces, but as one.
GRADE: A
OVERALL ANTHOLOGY GRADE: B
No comments:
Post a Comment